John Carter was initially portrayed as a desperate partner desperate to find his missing fiancée, Katelyn Markham. However, more than a decade later, he was indicted on two counts of murder in her death. Prosecutors later agreed to drop the charges in exchange for a plea to the lesser crime of involuntary manslaughter. On July 18, 2023, Carter was sentenced to the maximum prison term of three years in Ohio.
Prosecutors pursued charges against Carter after finding disturbing poems in his journal indicating a desire to harm Markham. Witnesses reported seeing suspicious activity at Carter’s home on the night Markham vanished. Carter’s alibi, based on his computer activity, was also called into question. Investigators uncovered details challenging Carter’s account and found circumstantial evidence linking him to Markham’s death.
Despite lacking forensic or eyewitness evidence, prosecutors believed Carter’s guilt based on the circumstantial evidence. Carter pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter to avoid a trial. No negotiation was made to have him provide an account of Markham’s death in the plea deal.
Markham’s father supported the plea deal, fearing that Carter could have walked free if the case had gone to trial. While the cause of Markham’s death remains unknown, Gmoser believed that securing a guilty plea was more important than a potentially risky trial. The decision to drop murder charges and accept a plea deal was made to ensure some form of justice for Markham.
Photo credit
www.nbcnews.com